Smith v My Media World and Butt Settled

Judge's Hammer Coming Down on Gavel

The settlement in this case was sealed today on the direction of High Court Master Thornett.

My claim against Brand New Tube and its Director Muhammad Butt has been settled, relatively amicably, following on from the discontinuance of their counterclaim against me.

In short, the settlement provides a permanent requirement that the Defendants will not repeat certain allegations. I am not under any similar restriction. They will pay my costs of my application to strike-out the Defence and Counterclaim. I will pay a sum towards their application to amend their defence, and otherwise pay my costs of the claim and their costs of their defence. They are separately obliged by the discontinuance to pay my costs of my successful defence to the counterclaim and to bear their costs of their counterclaim. This is likely to lead to a net payment from me to them, although of course they will have effectively made a large overall loss.

I am backed by a sponsor and will not pay my own costs. The sums involved are relatively modest and I have achieved my goals. The precise amount is not yet fixed because it will be subject to assessment if not agreed.

I am taking a relatively moderate approach to publicising this because I have considerably more sympathy for Muhammad Butt than Sonia Poulton and because in principle, I think Brand New Tube is a good idea. It is clear from his appearance on Rise this morning that Muhammad has come to appreciate some of the nuances of running such a platform. It is my hope he will now take a more conciliatory approach, especially given the many challenges his platform faces. Time will tell.

Share Button
This entry was posted in Brand New Tube, Free Speech, John Hemming, Law, Muhammad Butt, Samuel Collingwood Smith, Sonia Poulton by Samuel Collingwood Smith. Bookmark the permalink.

About Samuel Collingwood Smith

Samuel Collingwood Smith was born in the north of England, but his family moved south early in his life and spent most of his early years in Hertfordshire before attending Queen Mary, University of London, where he studied Economics. Sam currently lives in the southeast of England. Smith was employed as a Labour Party fundraiser in the 2001 General Election, and as a Labour Party Organiser in the 2005 General Election. In 2005 Smith was elected as a Borough Councillor and served for 3 years until 2008. In 2009 Smith changed sides to the Conservative party citing division within Labour ranks, Labour broken promises and Conservative improvements to local services. In 2012 Smith started to study a Graduate Diploma in Law, passing in 2014. Smith then moved on to studying a Master's Degree in Law combined with an LPC, receiving an LL.M LPC (with Commendation) in January 2017. During his study, Smith assisted several individuals in high profile court cases as a McKenzie Friend - in one case being praised by Parliamentary petition for his charitable work and legal skills. Smith is also the author of this blog, Matthew Hopkins News, that deals with case law around Family and Mental Capacity issues. The blog also opposes online drama and abuse and criticises extreme-left politicians.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *